Compare renters insurance. Know what you're buying.

The right policy starts with your home, your belongings and the people who need coverage—not an advertised starting price. Compare the details that matter before you choose.

Four things to compare

  • Who is covered?

    Do you need a policy just for yourself, or coverage for roommates too? Check who qualifies as an insured and whether the coverage limit is shared.

  • What would a claim pay?

    Match the personal property limit and deductible. Check replacement cost versus depreciated value, limits on valuables, exclusions and any extra coverage you need.

  • What is the full cost?

    Compare quotes for the same address, start date, limits and payment schedule. Include applicable fees. If a bundle changes another policy's price, compare the combined cost too.

  • How will you manage the policy?

    Look at how you update coverage, get proof for your landlord, ask for help and report a claim. Pick an arrangement that works for you, not just the lowest number on a quote.

How Goodcover compares

Goodcover vs. Lemonade

Both offer renters insurance online. Some roommates named on the lease may qualify under Goodcover policies, subject to policy definitions and shared limits. Lemonade's renters FAQ says unrelated roommates need their own policies.

A shared policy also means shared coverage limits. Confirm the terms for your household before choosing.

Compare Goodcover and Lemonade

Goodcover vs. State Farm

Check how each policy insures your household. Some lease-listed roommates may qualify under Goodcover policies, subject to policy definitions and shared limits. State Farm's renters FAQ says unrelated roommates need to be listed on the policy.

Compare household needs, policy management and the total cost of any auto-and-renters bundle.

Compare Goodcover and State Farm

Goodcover vs. Allstate

Compare roommate coverage questions, policy management and any auto-and-renters bundle. Some lease-listed roommates may qualify under Goodcover policies, subject to policy definitions and shared limits.

Allstate offers digital tools alongside agents and customer support. Confirm its roommate terms for your household and compare matched quotes.

Compare Goodcover and Allstate

Goodcover vs. Progressive

Progressive places property policies through an agency with affiliated and unaffiliated insurers. Check the underwriting company and how the quote channel affects the options offered to you.

Compare household coverage and the full auto-plus-renters cost—not an advertised discount alone.

Compare Goodcover and Progressive

Goodcover vs. Assurant

Look beyond an apartment community's insurance offer. Assurant's direct renters program has specific instructions for naming roommates and delivering proof to a landlord.

Distinguish a renters policy from a residents-liability product, then compare the insurer, coverage and full-term cost.

Compare Goodcover and Assurant

Before you switch

Make sure your new coverage is bound with the right start date before ending your old policy. Check your old insurer's cancellation and refund terms, then give your landlord updated proof of insurance.

About these comparisons

These comparisons are prepared by Goodcover, not an independent ranking service. We use the companies' published information and identify when it was checked. We do not claim one company is always cheaper or pays claims faster.

Goodcover is an insurance agency. Coverage is provided by the insurer named in your policy documents. Eligibility, coverage and pricing depend on your address and policy terms.